At the start of 2008 a friend of mine predicted that it would be the year of the Black Man, and as the year evolved he was proved to be right.

It was the 40 year anniversary of Martin Luther King’s assassination, but it was also the year the world had its first year Black F1 racing champion (Lewis Hamilton), the year a Black man captained the England football team (Rio Ferdinand), and the first Black man to manage a premiership football team (Paul Ince).  Most significantly it was the year that Barack Obama became the first Black President of the United States. When Obama won the Presidential election, Black people the world over were filled with pride and new hope.  On the morning after his election victory I like many others received this text message.

Rosa Parks sat,

so that Martin Luther King could walk,

so that Barack Obama could stand,

so that our children can fly.

Does Obama's success mean that racism is no longer a barrier to success?

Does Obama’s success mean that racism is no longer a barrier to success?

But were Black people right to feel such pride?  Barack Obama can be claimed by whites just as much as he is by Blacks.  He is infact of dual racial heritage, as is Lewis Hamilton, and Rio Ferdinand.  And Obama was not part of that American civil rights legacy of struggle.  None of the ancestors on the Black side of his family came to America in slave ships, they were never cotton pickers or share croppers, and they never marched for freedom in the 60’s.   When his African father met his white mother it was as an overseas student at the University of Hawaii. Obama spent only a matter of days with his father and was raised by his white mother and his white grandparents. It occurred to me that maybe it was because of his unique racial heritage that he had the confidence to run for President when no-one gave him a chance.  He didn’t listen to all those people, (particularly Black ones, myself included) that said a Black man could never be President.  Just like those who said that ‘Black men don’t play Golf’ before Tiger Woods came along, or that ‘F1 racing is not a Black man’s sport’ before Lewis Hamilton.   Maybe it was because he wasn’t hampered by those shackles of mental slavery that he was able to succeed so spectacularly.

Lewis Hamilton - another successful Black man breaking down barriers.

Lewis Hamilton – another successful Black man breaking down barriers.

But what about the rest of us? Can the success of Obama, and Hamilton, and Ferdinand inspire Black men throughout the diaspora to new heights?  We sure as hell hope so, because aside from those success stories, most ordinary Black men are struggling.  We are over-represented in all the places that we don’t want to be – the school exclusion figures, the young offenders institutions, the prisons, and the psychiatric units – and under-represented in all the places we should be – university graduation ceremonies, in the boardrooms, at the business breakfasts and business dinners, at the school parents’ evenings, on the schools’ boards of governors, even in the park playing ball with our sons.

In the States 47% of the penal population is African-American, but only 3.5% of the college students. We are 37% of the schools suspensions and have the lowest life expectancy. We have the highest homicide and cancer rates, and over 30% of the African-American males between 18 and 25 are unemployed.

In the introduction to his excellent book Outliers, another high achiever of mixed parentage Malcolm Gladwell argues that when looking at success stories we should not ask ‘what are they like?’ but rather examine the circumstances of their birth for clues to the secrets of their success.  In my examination of the failure of Black men I will do the same thing and argue that when we look at the many areas in which Black men are failing, we should not look at the particular failings of these individuals, but instead look at the circumstances of their birth for clues to the origins of this malaise that blights the Black community.  This is not to let off the hook those Black men who are bad fathers, or gang members, or drug dealers, or prison inmates, but rather to understand the phenomenon.  Once we can understand the causes of the problem we can go about changing it.

Mal;colm Gladwell - his book 'Outliers' examines what it takes to be a success.

Mal;colm Gladwell – his book ‘Outliers’ examines what it takes to be a success.

In The Problem With Black Men I have separated what I see as the Black community’s main problems into five areas and address each problem in turn with its own chapter.  At the end of each chapter I offer solutions – things that can be done on a personal individual level to improve the situation.  For each of these topics there are those that argue that the root cause is institutional racism.  Black boys are excluded from schools in such numbers because of the racism of the teachers.  They enter the penal system in such numbers because of the racism of law enforcement officers, and are misdiagnosed as schizophrenic because of the racism of mental health professionals.  They struggle to find employment because employers are unwilling to employ Black men, and thus contribute to the break-up of the Black family because whilst Black men are denied access to the world of work, Black women are let through, and are thus leaving their Black men behind.  All of these explanations maybe true, but if we just blindly accept them then we are accepting the role of mere victims. We are giving all the power to ‘the other man’, and there is nothing that we can do except to ask very politely if the white man would be so kind as to remove his foot from our necks!  I for one am tired of waiting for a kindly white man to come along and save us.  That is why, whilst acknowledging the role that white racism has to play, I am putting the onus firmly on Black folks, as the causes of and the solutions to our problems.

My book 'The Problem with Black Men' offers  solutions to our problems.

My book ‘The Problem with Black Men’ offers solutions to our problems.


The Problem With Black Men is available now on Amazon on both paperback and Kindle formats

  1. devon dc says:

    Congrats, a timely contribution to addressing one of the biggest issues in our communities.

  2. A necessary but unpopular proposition, Lee.

    Women awaited that same “white man” to dispense Equal Rights for centuries. When we got fed up waiting, we were Man-Haters, Bra-Burners, Lesbians…

  3. Louise Bennett says:

    Although I recognise and believe everything you say above. I find it hard to reconcile this with the fact that 50 per cent of black man date and marry outside their race (often white women). I am ready for the accusation of bitterness – which is true to the extent that black people have ‘a chip on their shoulder’ but I really feel a large problem with the black community is often when a black man becomes successful they will go ‘white’. Have you noticed some of the strongest and most successful races – jewish, indian, chinese, middle/upper-class white mainly stick together relationship-wise. I feel until we address this issue black people will continue to be disadvantaged in society.

    • leepinkerton says:

      Hi Louise. Thank you for your comment. I think the ‘dating outside of our race’ is a symptom of a wider problem. We have a lack of unity, and a lost culture. Without a unifying culture or a common purpose then it is impossible for us to stick together. If we are only thinking about our own advancement then it might make sense to partner with someone from ‘the host nation’. if we are thinking about the advancement of our race as a whole, then we might think differently.

  4. Louise Bennett says:

    Thanks for the response Lee. Going deep if I may. I believe this has been a problem with the black race from the days of slavery – from Africans selling their fellow men and women as slaves to the Europeans to today with powerful black male musicians often choosing to support and mentor white female artists over black (for example and cheryl cole; most recently lil wayne and paris hilton) – black people too often think about their own advancement and not about the uplifting of their race. So I’m kinda done with it all. Too much selfishness, hate and bad minds. But, I will buy your book..

    • leepinkerton says:

      Louise. can’t knock the likes of Lil Wayne and Will I Am for working with white artists – they’re trying to get paid, and they know the easiest way to do that. Remember that the Black Eyes Peas were just another struggling rap group and never had any mainstream success til they brought in Fergie. But don’t get downhearted by looking at Black men who appear to be ‘selling out’. Take heart from the few of us who are doing the right thing – and there are still a few of us!

      • Louise Bennett says:

        I see your point to an extent. But Lil Wayne and Will I Am are established artists now. Note I said Cheryl Cole – who Will I Am supports at the height of his career, not Fergie. And this excuse about ‘getting paid’ – it’s the same excuse that white magazines use not to put black models on their covers because they sell less, or why white mainstream companies won’t put blacks in their boardrooms – as they might not generate business and effect profit.

        If we don’t support our own, who will? It starts with us. And you are right. There are a few black men in support of the cause…

  5. Illrette Cummings says:

    I agree that both black men and women and the black community as a whole need to look at our challenges and refuse to accept a victim mentality it is debilitating. History demonstrates that we as black people have had to fight our rights to be treated as whe human beings in a white supremist society. So we need to go to the root of our problems and create start to create sulutions that support the physical,psychological, educational and spiritual growth for current and future generations.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s